.jpg)
There are some technologies that are hallmarks of the future societies seen in the works of science fiction: humanoid robots, easy space travel, off-world colonies, super-computers that are self-aware, flying cars, time-traveling Deloreans, jetpacks, and of course, laser guns. These futuristic weapons span the history of science fiction, with their origins being traced back to the holy pages of H.G. Wells'
War of the Worlds, onward today. Lasers can be seen in sci-fi heavyweights like
Star Trek,
Star Wars, all the way down to such classics of western cinema as
Yor: Hunter from the Future and
Masters of the Universe. The dream by man to use the power of light to kill is an ancient one...and any of a ten-year old boy with a magnifying glass, sunny day, and an ant hill. Yeah, we're kind of a fucked up species. Anyway, using light for warfare seemed like long-held fantasy, only recently has been made more of a reality, but not the levels that early sci-fi creators predicted. Unlike many of the directed-energy weapon (DEW) devicess pulled from science fiction, laser-based weaponry exists and by the mid-2020's, the US Army and US Navy will be fielding laser DEW devices. This has presented a challenge for FWS. While most of the fictionalized weaponry of science fiction is either impossible or theoretical at best, frickin' laser beams exist and I do not have a science background to the degree that the guys that crafts
Atomic Rockets or
Rocketpunk Manifesto do. For years, I promised this blogpost, but I was scared to write it and let down FWS readers that asked for...yeah, Christoper Phoenix, I'm talking about you! Especially after the failure of the last
Flash Fictional Serial I did in 2012. So, for 2014, I decided to Cowboy-the-fuck-up, and write this bitch that took two months of research and writing. So, here we go: Lasers: the Killer Light!
What is a Laser?
The word LASER is an acronym for
Light
Amplification by
Stimulated
Emission of
Radiation and the term was invented by Dr. Gordon Gould in 1957. lasers are tools of the medical field, video game consoles, DVD players, and scanners that are used everyday. Lasers are tightly focused sources of light that have converted energy into the release of photons. With the proper amount of focus and power, lasers can burn holes into metal or cut bone. Laser require several key elements of design. First, lasers need a lasing medium or a source of atoms of various matter that are excited to generate light at a certain wavelength. Second, a pump source that varies from a light bulb to a nuclear explosion that excites the atoms. Third, is the laser medium that also greatly varies from crystals, to gases, to liquids. And lastly, the lens or optical resonator to focus the beam. Depending on the elements used in the construction of your laser, there will be differences on the type of beam, wavelength, its power and use.
The Different Types of Military Lasers
-
Solid State Lasers
SSLs use a gain medium, such as crystals (rubies), rare Earth elements, or ions; that is a solid, instead of a gas or liquid and is optical pumped., or light used to boost a lower energy electrons to a higher level of energy. The most common SSL is YAG laser that fires at 1.06 micrometer wavelength, and is used in the medical field for laser eye surgery and hair removal. YAG are also used in the military for laser rangefinders, and laser designators. YAG or Yttrium Aluminium Garnet is a synthetic crystalline material from the garnet gemstone. At the moment, a SSL DEW is being developed for the F-35 JSF as an option, it could be a replacement for the normal GAU-22A four-barreled 25mm cannon.
-X-Ray Lasers
The term "X-Ray Lasers" is used in sci-fi circles and sounds rad, but in strict terms, an DEW that uses X-ray laser beams would need to use "Hard" X-Ray beams, like those in medical scans. The issue for X-ray laser DEW devices is focus and would ideal for space combat. Also X-ray lasers could kill human targets and electronic with radiation without harming building. X-ray laser have been used in scientific study of atoms, and the largest x-ray laser in California at SLAC.
-Gas Lasers
Gas lasers use a gain medium that is a single or combination of gases. The electrical current is shot through a gas to create a frickin' laser beam. The first example of a gas laser was created in 1960 using helium and neon gases. Much as been made of CO2 lasers in science fiction works and in the real-world for their high efficiency, about 30%, stable beam, and the most options with beam and output choices. Gas lasers are the cheapest to use, and are quite common in the industry field for wielding and cutting.
-Free Electron Lasers (FEL)
The FEL was developed by Stanford physicist John Madey in 1976, and is one of the laser classifications being evaluated by military organizations for DEW devices. The FEL uses a beam of electrons is pushed via particle accelerator to nearly the speed of light, the the electrons are moved through a field of magnets that are arranged with north and south poles facing the stream of electrons. This creates a "wiggle" in the electron stream, emitting light on a wavelength, and a change in the magnets alters the wavelength of the FEL beam. While FEL is consider one of the powerful lasers for military application, there are issue with FEL. One being the size of the laser equipment, the need for vacuum pumps, power requirements. Still, the US Navy is moving ahead with FEL laser emitters for their ships and tested the FEL laser around 2011 in the 14 KW power range.
-Chemical Oxygen Iodine Laser (COIL)
The COIL is a infrared chemical laser that is on invisible wavelength, invented around 1977, and is being tested for military weapons application. Various chemicals, like iodine and chlorine, are used to product heat and excited oxygen, then the gas flow is accelerated to hyper-velocity into a expansion nozzle. COIL DEW were being tested for the YAL-1 Airborne Laser, and this is one of those laser weapons that needs to be recharged with the chemicals mentioned above.
Fiber Optic Laser
One laser type getting much attention by the military is the fiber optic laser emitter. Using rare-Earth elements, the fiber optic laser is seen with some serious advantages over other laser types. Fiber optic lasers are more reliable with less upkeep, better cooling, less complexity, and more power efficient. This as caused a majority of the laser weaponry being tested, like Lockheed-Martin's successful test of a 30kW fiber optic laser in February of 2014. An interesting note, fiber optic lasers are being developed for a robotic off-world mining operation that could explore the icy moon of Jupiter: Europa.
What Would a Laser Weapon Look Like?
Science fiction has depicted the laser gun in various ways, everything from the iconic blasters of
Star Wars, the phasers of
Trek, and the ray guns of classic B science fiction films. But, what would a real laser weapon look and sound like? Laser emitters would be more camera-like than gun-like, think of news cameras, with the lens and more tube-like shape. The
HALO SPARTAN Laser matches this design. Some larger scale laser emitters would appear more like searchlights, like the US Army THEL DEW device. What would a laser weapon sound like? Surprise, sci-fi gets this wrong as well. Most real-world laser emitter being tested do not have much in the way of noise, especially when compared to their kinetic energy weapon counterparts. Some emit a low hum or buzz, or even a sizzle, or even nothing at all.
Some Data on Power Output
.jpg)
Sometimes, it is all about perspective, and when it comes to laser weapons, we need some perspective on the power output levels being thrown around here on this blogpost. The information comes from the Popular Mechanics website.
1-10 miliwatts (mW) is equal to a current laser pointers, CD-ROMs, and DVD and ...no lethality. Sorry.
500 mW is equal to most medical lasers for cosmetic procedures
5.0 watts is equal to a laser capable of burning wood or lighting your cigar.
60 watts is equal to those laser beams you see at laser rock shows...you know, the ones where you smoke out and listen to some Led-Zeppelin while tripping on the pretty laser beams. Am I the only one here?
100 watts- is equal to the CO2 lasers used in surgical procedures
200 watts is equal to the industrial CO2 lasers.
15,000 watts equal to a beam that can burn a boat
1 kilowatt is equal to a beam that cut metal plates.
15 kilowatt is equal to the US Navy's LsWS SSL DEW.
50 kilowatts is equal to a German point-defense laser system being tested.
100 kilowatts is the goal of the US military's MILSPEC DEW devices, it is the threshold for offensive military DEW devices. Frickin' laser tanks, man!
1 megawatt is equal to the goal of the SDI spaceborne defense laser systems
The Advantages of Laser Weapons
"Dial-A-Threat" Power Levels
It is the norm to see police officers carrying those TASER X26 less-lethal devices today. This gives the police officers options when confronted with an situation, instead of just relaying on their pistol or their nightstick (do they still carry those?). After all, attempting a "wounding shot" is tricky, and bullets ballistics are unpredictable once the slug enters the body. With the military, as we've seen in Iraq, fighting in larger urban areas were the enemy-civilian line is blurred, the assault rifle makes a poor crowd control device. Laser weaponry could be a real benefit to the soldiers of the future, that can choice to send civilians away from their position with a "heat pain ray", blind electronics and enemy troops, or flip the switch, and burn those mother fuckers! This dazzler effect has been a popular option in real-world laser weaponry, and it could prove one of the realistic real-world applications of laser DEWs.
Speed of Light
One of the reasons often cited by the US military for developing laser weaponry is that they move at the speed of light. This allows the beam to intercept the threat instantly and allow maximum amount of dwelling time. When you see the target, you can engage the target at the same moment. Consider this: the avenage paintball field allows for the .68 ball to have a maximum velocity of 280 feet-per-second. The 5.56x45mm round that is chambered in the M4A1 carbine as a velocity of 3,100 feet-per-second. While the laser beam would move at 983,571,056 feet-per-second!
More Ammunition
Remember those shitty-good 1980's action moves were the overly muscled hero just pumps thousands of rounds into everything? That is what some believe that a laser, tied to a major power source, could be. One of the reasons for the US Navy fielding their seaborne laser point-defense system is that unlike the Phalanx CIWS or the Mark 45 127mm cannon, the Navy laser as endless ammunition...well...as long as the nuclear generator works.
Accuracy
Most military lasers being developed are designed with the role of point-defense, due to the accuracy of the laser over missiles or bullets. Today, point-defense is handled by weapon systems like the Phalanx CIWS that unleashes a shit-ton of rounds at the incoming target, using the volume of fire approach to stop the threat. With the accuracy of a laser beam, especially those controlled by computers, can target the booster rocket of an incoming ICBM, the motor of suicide boat, or the tires of a suicide bomber's car, more effectively neutralizing the threat and preventing stray bullet hits.
Invisible Beams
When I watched the US Army THEL tests against mortar shells and the US Navy beams vs. drone test, one thing stroke me...how effortlessness the laser emitter looked while operating. While fury was being unleashed on the target, there was no indication that anything was happening, and these invisible beams could be a huge tactical advantage, especially in the role of a sniper laser system. There is just something so damned eerie about a weapon that can kill without be seen or really heard.
Cost-Per-Beam
If the laser DEW device was hookup to the local nuclear power plant and a effective cooling system, than unlike normal slugthrowers, you can fire for cheap. How cheap? The US Navy LaWS seaborne solid-state laser can be fired for a dollar-a-beam. That saves money over the normal point-defense systems that the ship would normally relay on: missiles and shells.
The Disadvantages of Laser Weapons
Power Requirements
The Achilles Heel of lasers can be summed in one word: power. Laser soak up power like a drunk at an open bar, and their thirst nature causes MILSPEC laser DEW devices to be tied to some pretty heavy duty power sources, and worse of all, lasers are notoriously inefficient. The laser DEW systems being tested by the US military are either onboard a nuclear powered warship or in the case of the Army's laser truck, tied to a massive "mobile" power supply. The power requirement only climb when you talk about using the laser for killing humans... that could be one of the main reasons that we may never seen handheld laser blasters. I can still remember back when I got my Worlds of Wonder Lazer Tag sets in Christmas of 1986, that the sci-fi awesome pistol, the Starlyte required
six mother fucking AA batteries! When Boeing and the USAF were testing the Boeing YAL-1 Airborne Laser system, a fire a five-second beam from the COIL DEW was equal an hour's power usage by typical American household. That was to take out one incoming missile during boosting phase.
Lethality
Laser work much differently than today's kinetic slugthrowers. Bullets use speed to transfer their energy to kill their target. Lasers kill via thermal damage, and just like microwaving your Hotpocket, it takes time. While a laser beam would move at the speed of light, and it would hit the target instantaneously, in order for it to be an effective weapon especially against the living; it needs to have a similar lethal profile as an current assault rifle ammunition. Lasers in science fiction seem instantly lethal, killing stormtroopers and Cylons with one discharge of the blaster, but real laser weapons need time-on-target, called dwelling time, to transfer the energy onto the target.
.gif)
If we examine military lasers, they are used against targets will some sort of combustible During testing, the US Army's THEL was able to take out a incoming mortar shell in about 3-4 seconds. The power output would need to be increased if the laser beam was targeting living soldiers and not shells, around a beam that was a capable of hitting our enemy infantryman with over 50,000 joules in order to burn a hole in their flesh fast enough to prevent the human from leaping out of the way of the burning sensation. That would be a person without armor...any future battlefield with laser beams as a possibility would be wearing armor to deal with it with ceramic or aerogel...that would mean we need more energy to overcome the body armor. Also, a soldier would be wearing sensors to detect the moment a laser beam made contact. To make our laser assault rifle have the level lethality needed to be battlefield capability, there be a need to increase the power requirements, much means increasing the size of the power pack. All three of these factors are linked.
The Power Pack
In most sci-fi works, the laser gun is roughly the same size as a current slugthrower handgun, or even smaller, just look at the
Star Trek Type-I hand phaser! Without some sci-fi far-future power storage device, lasers will have to be tied to a large power sources. That creates some issues. With man-portable laser DEW devices would be more
GI Joe Flash's laser rifle and the
Akira beam rifle than the DL-44 blaster. It is likely that any man-portable laser weapon would be literally tied to a battery pack like the Photon Pack from
Ghostbusters, and this could present a really issue during close-quarters-combat, and long recon missions. After all, don't soldiers have enough to hump? This just not apply to the fictional handheld laser gun, this is an issue faced by current military laser DEWs. The Airborne Laser needed a massive amount of power, and the Boeing plane struggled to fuel the laser beam. The same is true of the mobile truck laser that the US Army is testing, because it needs a truck to haul around the power generator.
Cooling Systems
Given that lasers convert energy into light, and the energy that is lost is expressed in heat, and with laser beams needing dwelling time...all of this adds up to heat. Heat needs to shuttled away from the laser weapon or shut down and damage will result. This will be more of an issue in space-based laser systems than back here on Earth, but it still is an issue, and that adds only complexity and weight to our future laser guns. The US Navy as solved some of this issue with using sea water to cool their LaWS. The problem would become worse with hand-held DEW devices. As Ken Burnside put it to me: "
You'll also have the not-so-trivial task of not cooking the hands of the person using the weapon."
Thermal Blooming
The laser as natural enemies found in normal everyday environmental conditions: fog, dust, smoke, clouds, rain, inclement weather conditions. All of these decrease the laser beams effectiveness, range, and lethality. These could be used as countermeasures to incoming laser beams, and issues for depolying laser to certain battlefields. I read that a comment that said lasers would be less useful in very polluted cities, like Tokyo, Mexico City, and well, most China. The overall big term in laser weaponry for this issue is thermal blooming. Thermal blooming is when laser beams ionize (or plasma) the atmosphere, and this shatters the beam in the surrounding air. The factors of fog, smoke, and dust increase the issues of thermal blooming and destroy the effectiveness of your death ray. If we were to use lasers on a world with greater atmospheric density that thermal blooming could render laser weaponry ineffective.
In-Field Conditions
Let's face it, being a foot soldiers as
always sucked, from the days of the Romans all the way today. Conditions in field are dirty, hot, cold, windy, sandy, and so on. Soldiers today go into battle with a number of electronic devices, like computers and night-vision devices, that met certain levels of roughness that allow them to survive the chaotic nature of the battlefield. Besides the issues of the beam getting screwed with, there is the issue of keeping the laser emitter clean. If and when the laser weapon needed a clean or repair, could a special operator in the deep jungle or mountains of Afghanistan posse the needed technical skill to service a laser weapon? Consider that the Navy's own LaWS DEW is under the protection of a dome enclosure until needed to protect it from damage...if they have to do that, than how could it survive the sandstorms of Iraq?
The History of Military Lasers
During the 2nd Punic War, The Romans laid siege
to the city of Syracuse, in Sicily, due to the once friendly Kingdom of
Syracuse had turned against Rome. From 214-212 BCE, the Roman fleet lay siege
to the city in attempt to maintain control over Sicily. Aiding the city
defenders was none other than Greek inventor Archimedes. One of the weapons
that he developed in the two year long ordeal was a “heat ray”, that used mirrors to light the Roman ship alit. While it
could be done in the 2nd century BCE, and modern experiments confirm
that you can set a ship ablazing with a burning mirror, it is likely that it
the weapon that Archimedes developed was steam-powered cannon that fired clay “cannon”
balls filled with flammable liquid rather than massive mirror to focus
sunlight. From the 2nd century BCE all the way to the 19th century. there was little in the way of invention or advancement on using light as a weapon.
However, that would change in the 20th century when an explosion of inventors and crackpots all attempting to develop the mythical "death ray". One man who may have actually was one of the greatest minds of the 20th century, Nikola Tesla. Nikola Tesla. Tesla had been fooling
around with X-ray since the 1890’s, even firing x-rays across the room. It is
believed that Tesla may have developed the first ruby red laser around 1893 and
demonstrated the technology to the general public, and around 1918, sent pulses
to the Moon. No wonder the moon people hate us! Most of this is unconfirmed,
though. What is true is that Tesla was fooling around with a DEW device called
the “Peace Ray” that would be a weapon to create world peace. Even on Tesla’s
dead bed, he swore that he developed the weapon that, according to some
sources, was more of a particle beam than a laser weapon that could reap damage
on a level of WMD…but we will never know. Some sources believe that the plans
for the Tesla Death Ray were stolen. The fingers have been pointed to any
number of the usual suspects: aliens, MIB, Nazis, Freemasons, and the US
government.
One daring directed-energy weapon system was proposed in 1929 by Hermann Oberth, and involved a massive 100-meter wide concave mirror above the Earth that could reflect sun light onto the Earth's surface. During the mid-1940's, the Nazi research facility at Hillersleben explored the possibility of an orbital weapon platform that could focus light with the power to boil oceans and burn cities. Unlike the original 1929 mirror, the "Sun Gun" would have required a mirror miles in diameter with an entire space program to construct it in orbit in sections via shuttle-like rocket spacecraft from the original 1945 Nazi concept art. During World War II, both the Nazis and the Imperial Japanese
worked on “death rays’ of their own either were lasers in the true sense. Besides
Tesla, two other inventors claimed that they had developed death rays. One was
a German inventor forced to leave Paris with this Magnesium powered Death Ray
that could stunning Pigeons from a mile away. This 1935 Death Ray looked more
like a bullhorn than a ray gun. The other case of the Death Ray was from Dr.
Antonio Longoria around the 1930’s, that he claimed was so deadly that it could
kill some animals even behind walls. The method of the lethality came from a process
that painless transformed blood into a substance that the body couldn't use. Fearing
his invention would be used for evil (imagine that!) and destroyed the device
and the plans. Pity.
During World War II, both the Axis powers worked on Death
Ray type devices. We have to remember that this point in history, the word
“laser” is not invented, and the world’s first working laser developed by Dr.
Ted Maiman was still twenty years away. These Death Rays of the 2nd
World War were more microwaves, particle accelerators, and even a plasma-based
DE system…nothing really came of them. With the Space Race and Arms Race of the
Cold War, the United States and her allies attempted to develop “space age”
weaponry, from the 1960’s through the 1970’s, lasers were under considering
with various amounts of funding. By the 1970’s, the USSR was actively
researching both ground-based laser DEW devices and space-based lasers for us
in anti-satellite weapons (ASAT) using free electron lasers. The Soviets really
took the notion of laser DEW devices as a symbol of Soviet pride and
technological progress. By the mid-1960’s, the Soviets were already working on
Project Omega, an air defense network of laser emitters, similar to the
proposed Skyguard laser area defense system by Northrop Gruman in 2012. Much of
the Soviet laser testing was conducted at “Terra-3”, at the Sary Shagan base in
the Kazakhstan, and began in 1965 all the way to the late 1980’s. Also, in the 1970’s, western scientists were also experimenting
with laser-based weaponry. By the mid-1970’s, it was strongly assumed by NATO intelligence
that the USSR had active MILSPEC laser technology, and that the West had a “laser
gap”. Beginning in 1976, the US Air Force started work on an Airborne laser
laboratory. The goal was to construct an airborne laser system to intercept
missiles and other airborne threats.The British began their own program to
develop laser technology in 1974 after a United State laser technological
breakthrough in 1972 with gas-laser technology, allowing for more
military-grade weapons tech. Both the British and Soviets attempt to mount “dazzler”
type laser systems on naval ships as a form of defense. It seems that there was
some success.
During the Falklands War of 1982, a dazzler type laser system was
installed on the British carrier HMS Hermes
(R12), and according to some sources, successful test in combat against Argentinian
aircraft, which would be the first use of a military laser in combat….if true.
Naval laser DE weapon systems were also experimented by the USSR. Around 1984
the Red Navy used a landing ship, the Foros,
to test a laser that could intercept incoming missiles, while successful; the
laser was more work than it was worth, causing the test to be concluded.
The
Russians also tested a laser weapon system on the cargo ship Dikson in the Black Sea around 1978. The
first weapons test of the cargo ship mounted laser occurred in 1980 with a 5%
energy output, and most of the lethality was sucked off due to atmospheric and environmental
scattering. These tests with the Dikson
continued until 1985, and more of a success, and the Russian navy moved forward
with plans to install lasers in a role in much the US Navy is planning now. It
is believed that the only Red Navy warship fitted with a laser was a member of
the Kirov class…but these are
unconfirmed. However, by 1989, both of the ships were scrapped, and the naval
laser plans were abandoned due to the change in the political climate of the
world.
During the 1980’s, most of the attention for laser weaponry
was focus on the “Star Wars” SDI program, and both the United States and the
Soviet Union entered into a technologically pissing contest. While space laser
platforms were being dreamed up on a scale of Moonraker, the Soviet Union had another laser program, the
so-called “laser tank”, the 1K17 Szhatie.
This interesting look armored vehicle was official called a “self –propelled laser
vehicle" that was based off the 2S19 Msta
self-propelled artillery piece, and mounted a forward looking battery of ruby
laser designed to “soft kill” NATO electronics and sensors, instead of roasting
infantry or burning M1 Abrams tanks. The offensive land warfare laser system
experimented with by the USSR was “Sangvin", a laser DEW variant of the
ZSU-23-4 AAA self-propelled artillery piece. While in the US, the US Navy MIRACL (mid-infrared advanced
chemical laser) project produced a deuterium fluoride laser weapon that held a
beam for 70 seconds, and by 1985, the DoD had their own dedicated laser
research facility at White Sands.
Of course, the real story with 1980’s military lasers can
best be summed up in three words: Strategic Defense Initiative (SDI).During the heady days of the SDI program, the idea of using laser beams to knock out incoming Soviet ICBMs gave the American public and Soviet officials visions of frickin' laser beams in outer space that could zap incoming nukes before they ever reached the shores of America. However, the reality was much more grim that most common people knew. The ability of launching unmanned laser attack satellites was much more fiction than science back in the early 1980's. While the American military-industrial complex moved forward with President Reagan's plan to put lasers into orbit, there was another way.
One more plausibly solution was to use ground-based powerful laser emitters to shot beams to space-based mirrors and intercept the incoming red rockets with redirect laser fire! This would have the advantage of the lasers using the power grid, and they could put into service much rapidly than the space-based laser DEW platforms. Of course, the energy would be lost between the surface and space, and MIT estimated back then that each space mirror would need to project a focused beam in the 40 MW range to damage the Soviet booster rocket skin. This would require, according to MIT, that the ground-based emitter to produce a beam in the 400 MW range! While some art of the time projected that the orbital mirror would be an out-and-out mirror, the reality was these, according to Atomic Rockets would be glorified mylar balloons.
It was also during the SDI program that the Soviets also looked at putting their own laser platforms into orbit for defensive purposes. The concern by the Reds was that if the United States could counter their ICBMs, that the US could launch their own nuclear strike without fear of a counterstrike by the Soviets. Some at the time within the USSR military believed that SDI was the first step in a all-out nuclear war to end the threat posed by the Warsaw Pact and the Soviet Union. During the apex of SDI fever, the Soviets examined their own in-house laser development, and started a program to get their SDI system.
It was called "Polyus-Skif". The Soviet builder of their spacecraft, Energia Organization explored that very idea of space-based lasers in the 1970's in conjunction with the program to construct Soviet military space stations that were armed. However, with the cancellation of the military space stations, caused the original Soviet space laser project to be languishing on the backburner until Reagan made his SDI speech in March of 1983. That sparked the Soviets to place Polyus-Skif on high priority and funded it accordingly. In order to get their space-based laser system up before the US, the Soviets were going to cannibalize an experimental one megawatt CO2 laser off of an abandoned airborne laser project, and launch into space via their normal rockets to demonstrate the technology as well as putting the West on notice. This CO2 laser weapon was from an project in 1981 to mount a laser on a military cargo plane, their Il-76 transport plane, much like our own old airborne laser. The experimental plane was called "Beriev A-60", and only two were built with limited success. The project to put the laser into space was called "Polyus" or "pole" in Russian, and it was rushed into production, so that the laser could be transported into orbit via the new rocket, the Energia rockets developed for the Soviet space shuttle, the Buran (snowstorm in Russian).
While the plan originally was to have the Polyus laser testbed transported into via the Buran space shuttle, the shuttle project was delayed, causing the Polyus project to go to Plan B, strap the laser onto the Energia rocket and test the laser in orbit. Unlike the American SDI program, the Soviets answer to the West was actually attempting to put hardware into space, rather than talk about it. However, the grand idea of Polyus didn't work out. With the rush job on the system, the 1987 launch ended in a complete loss of the spacecraft and the space laser, crashing down into the ocean. A faulty line of code caused the wrong burn sequence and re-position of the spacecraft's nose down towards Earth and not space, sending the spacecraft back towards the Earth and a fiery end. This cause the end of the Polyus-Skif project, and any other Soviet launches of the space-based laser system.
Interestingly enough, the American Air Force had also had idea of using the NASA Space Shuttle for the SDI program. While the Space Shuttle would have been the space transport system for the majority of hardware if the SDI program had become reality, there was also the plan to arm the Space Shuttle with a laser emitter. Yes. Arming the Space Shuttle. The Air Force had visions of their own military shuttle, but that was eliminated via budget cuts, but they turned to the NASA Space Shuttle for their frickin' space laser. The plan was to mount a laser emitter in the payload bay of the shuttle(s), to act has an ASAT and ABM weapons platform. These armed shuttles would have been launched in case of increased tension combination with the likelihood of a Soviet missile launch.
Then there is the rumors that surround the Terra-3 facility and their laser "attack" on the Space Shuttle Challenger on October 10th, 1984 during STS-41-G. While it is true that the Soviets were working on ground-based anti-satellite directed energy weaponry, it is questionable that the Soviets would have taken the risk of laser-flashing the shuttle. When US scientists finally got a look at Terra-3 facility in 1989, they determined that while the USSR were working on ground-based laser artillery, it was nowhere near as powerful as the then-current US Navy MIRACL one MW hydrogen
fluorite laser, and given the technology being used at Terra-3, the US scientists doubted that the facility couldn't have posed a threat. While the Soviets
were working on laser weaponry of all kinds, the US military was also
attempting to fill the requirements of SDI.
In 1985 at White Sands, New Mexico,
the DoD opened the High Energy Laser Systems Test Facility or HELSTF, and began
decades of laser weapons research. By the 1990’s the new united German,
embarked on a vehicle-based laser research project: HELEX. The goal of
HELEX was a mobile laser platform that used a gas dynamic CO2 laser of several
megawatts of power to intercept incoming missile threats. To get maximum
clearance, the HELEX was going to use a Leopard MBT shell with a extended neck
design to allow the laser emitter lens to poke above the trees and engage
incoming air threats. The project was cancelled sometime in the mid-1990’s due
to budget concerns. The HELEX along with other 1990’s laser DEW systems represented
an interesting time for laser DEW development. While the threat of the big bad
Soviet Union was over, Western nation, namely the United States worked to
develop MILSPEC high-energy laser weapon systems. According an 1992 article,
the future of laser development was being spurred on by fears in Europe and
America of the breakup of the Soviet Union and Warsaw Pact.
In 1996, the US the
Israel entered into a laser project, The Tactical High Energy Laser (THEL).
This deuterium fluoride laser would be tasked with point-defense against
incoming rockets and mortars. Between 2001-2002, the THEL would shot down incoming
threats with much success, and the THEL would pave the way for the IDF “Iron
Bar” area laser DE defense system. From the mid-1990's, to the early years of the 21st century, the US increased the effectivness of the THEL system, while Boeing
and the US Missile defense agency embarked on a daring laser project in 1996:
the airborne laser.
The goal was to have an aloft 747 with a one megawatt chemical
oxygen iodine laser (COIL), advanced sensor and targeting systems that would
all the powerful COIL DEW device to lock-on and burn the incoming missile in a
matter of seconds. Over the course of 16 years and billions of dollars, the
future looked bright for the Boeing YAL-1A testbest aircraft, the technology
was proven, but the effectiveness was not. The range of interception of
incoming missiles more limited that originally believed, due to atmospheric
conditions. This caused the aircraft to be in closer proximity to the target
that previous
thought. One example given online was if the Airborne Laser was
being sent to knock out an incoming Iranian missile, the aircraft would have to
be inside the borders of Iran. Not good. Also, the 747 had to be within a few
hundreds of miles of the launch site, and if it was a submarine launch than
forgot about it. In order for the tracking system and the laser to function
property, the plane had to be more or less level. All of this would mean that
the Airborne Laser 747 would have to be in the right place and the right time
to zap the incoming missile threat. By 2010, with costs mounting in Iraq and Afghanistan,
the DoD shut down the Airborne Laser project, boxing the hardware for a future
rainy day. If the Airborne Laser had been approved, there was chatter of a
laser DEW being mounted to a variant of the AC-130 gunships. Another cancelled
program was THEL US Army project was also cut back due to budget cuts and
issues with refueling the chemical lasers, instead the US Army moved towards a
mobile truck-mounted 100 KW HEL-MD project was successful tested in December of
2013, and there high hopes for this project. Also on the horizon of point-defense
laser DEW devices is the Israel offspring of the cancelled THEL, the “Iron
Bar”, which will work in conjunction with the missile point defense system
“Iron Dome”.
Lastly, the US Navy has been working on a seaborne laser weapon
system since the 1980’s, and a naval warship is a natural platform for a laser.
Given the greedy nature of a laser’s appetite, a nuclear-powered ship is a good
choice, and it seems that the US Navy agrees. Kratos Defense & Security
Solutions was awarded the contact for $11 million dollars to build a fiber
solid state laser that would use the current Phalanx CIWS point-defense system's tracking and targeting equipment to engage targets about a mile out, and zap them with one megawatt of power. Tests have been positives with the Naval LaWS DEW device engaging a incoming drone and an small boat. It is likely by the 2020's, the US Navy, Air Force, and Army will have some sort of defensive/offensive laser DEW system in place. Once again, by this point, there will be a "laser gap", and other nations are already in R&D for their own laser DEW systems.
The Mysterious Case of the Soviet 1984 Cosmonaut Laser Pistol
We all know that the Soviets had a thing for putting guns
into space. The first gun in space coincides with the first man in space. When
Yuri Gagarin launched into space in 1961, in his survival kit was a Makarov
9x18mm pistol. The interesting TP-82 survival space gun was carried by
Cosmonauts in case of landing in a remote location in Mother Russia until 2007.
However, during the Soviet obsession with frickin’ laser beam in the 1980’s,
the Soviet Military Academy of Strategic
Missile Forces (The USSR’s NORAD) developed a silver pistol that fired 10mm
bullets loaded with zirconium, foil, oxygen, and metal salt, all element
required for a pyrotechnic flash.
This flash made the little space laser pistol
an optically pumped solid state laser DEW device, but the power output was minimum,
about the same as an air rifle, however the pistol was not developed for
offensive space warfare, but for defense. Okay, leave it to the Reds to dream
this one up…they develop a weak space laser as a defensive armament for
Cosmonauts under attack from spacesuit soldiers. The laser’s sole purpose was
to pierce the spacesuit of the space soldiers, and allow the nature of outer space
to do its grim work. In this case, it really is that ray-guns don’t kill
spacemen. I assume that the Soviets were dreaming up tactical scenrios were the
US and the USSR battle over their space assets, and the US deploys specialized
space marines to take the Russian space platforms form them. Of course, it was
all a wet dream, and nothing really became of the space pistol, it never
reached beyond prototype stage, and one of the two examples is in the museum of
the military academy that developed the pistol. It is reported that the space
laser pistol is their most popular item.
Lasers in Today's Military
The majority of military lasers in service today are used for aiming and identifying a target, communications, and ranging. Systems like the SOFLAM use laser beams to designate a target, and feed the information to strike aircraft, allowing for accurate pinpoint close air support. Then we have Insight Technology AN/PEQ (P=man portable E=laser Q=special) series of laser aiming module (LAM) that attach to picatinny rails on modern carbines and assault rifles, like the Colt M4A1. The small boxes on the forward section of the weapon give the soldier options on the battlefield. The latest generation of the AN/PEQ series, the 16, is equiped with an visible and IR (for night vision) laser beams for aiming, normal LED, and an IR illumination mode. When the campaign began in Afghanistan, these laser aiming devices were more rare, however, by 2014, they are common place on nearly every M4A1 carbine.
Another use for lasers is force-on-force training. Since the 1980's, the US military, along with her NATO allies have used the IR tagging system, much like the civilian "lazer tag", called MILES to train-like-you-fight. While military organizations can and do train with Airsoft and Paintball, IR systems like MILES allow for soldiers to use their own guns, with blank fire adapters, to train in combat situations. Even armored vehicle crews use a form of the MILES gear to train with OPFOR units. One of the largest armored force-on-force training ground is at 29 Palms.
Why is the Military Developing Laser Weapons?
Why are modern military organization even bothering with spending the R&D costs on developing an MILSPEC laser DEW system? Is it because Dr. Insano is in change of the Pentagon's secret labs in Dulce, New Mexico? Is it to defeat the Grey aliens that come to Earth to kill our cows and steal all of our Strawberry Ice Cream? Is because too many of us really desire a laser blaster to fulfill some childhood fantasy of being Han Solo? In reality, the US Military is pouring money into MILSPEC laser DE weaponry for their tactical flexibility and speed. With laser beams being damn-near instantaneous time-on-target weapon systems, they can be for point-defense, intercepting incoming mortar shells, rockets, ICBMs, drones, and small pirate boats. Unlike current defensive armaments like the old Patriot missile system, the IDF Trophy, and the naval Phalanx CIWS, laser beams moving at the speed of light, intercepting the threat earlier in distance and time, allowing for the threat to be neutralize before it can even get close to friendly forces. Given lasers pinpoint accuracy ability, the military envisions soldiers being able to target a boat's engine, or the tires of an hostile car approaching a check-point. Both of these case would allow for the threat to be counter in an effective manner without resorting to lethal action. Also, laser DEW devices could be modified as a useful psychology and/or less-lethal platform for crowd control and guard stations, like the Active Denial System.
Current Military Laser DEW Projects
The US Army's HEL MD Program
The US Army is currently testing a mobile laser DEW platform that is the offspring of the old THEL device, and is a continuation of the Army's vision of MILSPEC point-defense DEW system that is mobile to adapt to changing battlefield conditions. The HEL-MD is a testbed for that future mobile system. Currently, the HEL-MD is a mere 10KW solid-state laser emitter, and is being tested against incoming mortars. The hope is to upgrade to a 50KW then to the full 100KW mobile DEW system that will protect forward-operating-bases and urban sites from incoming fire.
The US Navy LaWS Program
This year, the US Navy amphibious transport dock USS
Ponce of the
Austin class will be the real-world testbed for the LaWS seaborne laser DEW device intended for point-defense against drones and boats. If successful with proven the military technology laser technology, than full-scale adoption of lasers in the Navy will began. The target date for that acceptance is around the 2020's. If this does happen, the Navy's seaborne laser DEW technology will be shared with NATO and other allies, like Israel and possibly Taiwan. It is also likely, if this happens, our enemies will move forward with their own laser DEW technology.
The Israeli Iron Beam Program
With the continued threat to the population centers of Israel and her West Bank settlements, two defense systems are under development: Iron Dome and Iron Beam. Iron Dome is a missile point-defense interceptor system that was put in-field use in 2011. By 2012, over 400+ rockets were intercepted at a success rate of 90%. The Iron Beam uses a fiber optic laser to knock out targets at over 4 miles away from the emitter within 4-5 seconds of dwelling time. The Iron Beam is under tests at the moment, and proving itself.
The USAF 6th Generation Fighter Air-to-Air Laser
Much like the US Navy and US Army, the US Air Force is targeting the 2030's for the 6th generation of attack fighters to be armed with a laser DEW device instead of the normal rotary cannon. Currently, a laser weapon is under development for the F35 Joint-Strike Fighter, and will serve as real-world research for the next generation of military strike fighters. This airborne laser would allow tactical options for the pilot; dazzle, point-defense, scramming of electronics, and offensive ACM laser beam fire.
The German Rheinmetall HEL
The German defense company Rheinmetall is testing their own 50kW high energy laser DEW device for point-defense against shells, drones, rockets. Unlike other laser defense systems, the Rheinmetall HEL uses two laser emitters, one is a 20kW and another is 30kW, that both strike the target, in a beam equaling 50kW. It is hoped by Rheinmetall to field a 100kW emitter with side-by-side 50kW emitters. After successful interception tests, where the German laser in 2013 at a Switzerland test range hit and destroyed targets a one kilometer away, Rheinmetall will be testing a 60kW variant. It is likely, given Germany's history, that the Rheinmetall HEL will be also an export item.
The Indian laser Programs
There is little doubt that India and Pakistan are two of the nuclear armed nations with the greatest possibility of waging a nuclear war, and that as fueled the Indian KALI laser DEW program. Much like United State's old SDI project, the KALI is a defensive system to prevent Pakistan rockets from striking inside of India. Some articles call the KALI a "laser" while other sources say that the KALI is a linear electron accelerator. Besides the KALI, the Indian version of DARPA, DRDO, is working on laser interception batteries, like the US Army THEL, with power in the 25kW range. Also being developed is a dazzler weapon with a 10 kilometer range for air defense. This laser research as not gone unnoticed by China, Pakistan, and even Iran.
The Chinese Laser Programs
With Red China being the other Superpower to the United States, they are working on their own laser DEW devices. One is similar to the old Soviet anti-satellite Terra-3 laser battery, were the Chinese are developing ASAT lasers that can hit satellites as was proven with a Chinese laser strike on US satellites back in 2006. This base in the Tian Shan mountains continues to be a mystery, but with India and the US working on laser weaponry, the Chinese are also. One current laser system in the hands of the Chinese, is the ZM-87 portable laser disturber. This 15mW man-portable weapon is designed to dazzler enemy soldiers, and attack electronics with its Nd:YAG laser emitter. Developed in the 1980's, only 22 were built by the same Chinese arms company that created the Type-56 assault rifle around 2000, and production was ended due to the 1998 ban of laser blinders by the United Nations. Some were given the North Koreans, and they claim that they lit up two American Apache attack helicopters. This is the only man-portable laser DEW device ever adapted by a military organization.
Realistic Future Military Applications for Laser Weaponry
How would a future military organization realistic use DEW systems given everything that we have discussed? I think that laser DE weapons would not serve the same role as the assault rifles of today. In that role, kinetic energy weapons are just more effective and less costly in terms of energy for their intended combat role. It is likely that lasers would serve not as the primary armament, but a secondary, more defensive role. As seen in the epic
ALIENS: The Colonial Marines Technical Manual, laser weaponry is mostly used in a point-defense role on armed vehicles that intercept incoming missiles, drones, and aircraft. As for a main armament, we could see lasers being used as an active denial system or even an anti-aircraft vehicle assigned to defend a base or an armored unit, like the Russian ZSU-23-4 self propelled AAA gun. Despite a particle beam or even Gauss cannon being more effective against other tanks, there could be made a case for a main battle tank being armed with a laser emitter that could, if powerful enough, could drill holes in other tanks.
Laser weaponry will be seen in the arena of space combat in both defensive ans offensive roles. These laser emitters would be protected against the perils of space, just like a camera's lens. During space engagements, as
Atomic Rockets points out, whoever can get their lens cap off first, can zap first, and normally win the fight. Think of it like the torpedo tube doors on submarine, you can gauge the hostile intend and combat readiness via the status of the door (or lens in this case)...will only if they are not Minbari!
Can You Dodge a Laser Beam?
It is greatly depressing to see how common the trope of "slow moving laser beams" is in sci-fi, especially those works emerging after
Star Wars and
Star Trek. How the hell do you slow down light, anyways? Take it to Baskin-Robbins every day? Make it were a puffy jacket? Or how about, making the room colder? Jesus, did these people miss science class the day they talked about the speed of light? In word, no matter if you are a Jedi (and you are not), a robot, the Stig, or even a Frenchman, you cannot dodge incoming laser beams. By the time that you see it, you've already been hit. That is it. Sorry, Luke Skywalker and all the rest of the Jedi, that is the simply truth.
Can You Vaporize Someone with a Laser?
Beams that can completely blast someone into ashes has been around since
War of the Worlds, and popularized by science fiction works since. So, would it be possible to set phasers to disintegrate? You can reduce a human being into a pile of ashes by subjecting the body to intense high heat, like that found in an atomic blast or industrial smelting. The amount of energy it would take to break the atomic bonds and reduce our enemies to vapor is around 2.99 gigajoules. A gigjoule is equal to one billion joules of energy, and one gigjoule is equal to 947 cubic feet of natural gas. Another way to examine the energy requirements for disintegrating someone is that the nuclear reactor at Fort Calhoun in Nebraska generates some 502 MWs. From this information, I think it safe to say that the power output required to reduce your victim to ashes or nothingness confined to a man-portable laser DEW device is not possible at this time or realistic.
After all, why would you need this ability? Disintegration is not a current requirement of any military weapon system I know about. Even the laser weaponry being tested by the US military is mainly designed to burn a hole and/or start a fire, not vaporized into oblivion. Consider the 2005 War of the Worlds with Tom Cruise, the Tripod use powerful directed energy heat beams that nearly instantaneously transform running humans into dust and burned tatters of clothing.
While this is an impressive feat of weapon technology, and has a massive psychological impact on your enemy, as we witnessed in the film, it would also consume a great deal of energy, and needlessly so. What military advantage would it have? Soldiers are trained to kill their enemy, most weapon systems are designed to end the threat of their target; vaporizing an enemy soldier or a tank is just plain overkill. After all, a piece of metal no bigger than my finger projected at high velocity can and does kill effectively, and those alien Tripods could have strap some "old painless" rotary cannons to the bellies and mowed down those people from New Jersey just as easily, sparing the energy.
Bullets or Beams?
For generations of science fiction creators, the vote between beams or bullets was extremely in favor of the directed-energy type of weaponry. This trend lasted for nearly a hundred years..really until the mid-1980's, primary due to the impact of the 1986 film
ALIENS. Since around that time, sci-fi has reversed the trend of ray guns in the hands of future soldiers, putting more kinetic slug-throwers into the mix of science fiction works. This trend is even stronger since the turn of the century. While science fiction has more or made their vote, for now, about bullets vs. beams...what about that decision in the real world?
At the moment, science is unable to construct a MILSPEC laser DE weapon that could compete with the typical assault rifle in terms of lethality or portability. This counts also with other DE weaponry, like Particle beams and "plasma" guns. That could change in the future with the advent of something like the flexible carbon nanotube battery. Kentic slugthrowers offer a great deal of flexibility, reliability, and low-cost to a military organization. Bullets are so more efficient when it comes to delivery energy to the target than the current crop of laser weapons, and best of all, slugthrowers don't need a heavy-duty truck to cart them to the battlefield.
I recently asked this question to master game designer, and all around great human being Ken Burnside, who is creative director of Ad Astra Games: "
When you fire a bullet from a rifle, about 80% of the chemical energy imparted to the projectile sends it downrange. The remaining 20% is waste heat, ejected in the form of hot brass. The waste heat rejection issue is also why caseless ammo never really took off. In round numbers, a typical .223 (5.56mm) round delivers (975^2) * 0.0035 kgm/sec energy or about 3.3 kilojoules of energy to the target. It's dumping about .05 kilojoules in waste heat and hot gasses. Right now, lasers are about 7-15% efficient. For the sake of numbers, we'll call it 12.5%. That means that for every kilojoule you're delivering to the target, you'll need to get rid of 7 kilojoules of waste heat. Very roughly, cooking a 9oz New York Strip steak to medium-rare is about one kilojoule.
Against unarmored targets, lasers work best when they can cause some other chemical in the target to explode-jet fuel, propellant for a rocket, things like that. We currently lack any kind of laser than can penetrate serious vehicular or personal body armor. The first place you'll find man-portable laser DEWs will be in the sniper role, attacking from stealth. The laser should have a good range if it's using a visible light frequency, it won't have a visible light muzzle flash (expect for the person whose eye you just shot out!), and it'll have a much smaller audible signature, making the current techniques of counter-snioer echolocation infeasible. It will have a low cyclic rate of rifle, as a sniper rifle does." I then posed the question of what he would rather take into combat: AR-15, AK-47, or a laser DEW rifle?
"AR-15. It won't have the range of the laser, but it will be more accurate than the AK-47. Plus, more shots per kilogram of "ammo" than either of them".
Why Are Lasers So Popular in Sci-Fi?
When I started work on this blogpost, I knew that the connection between science fiction and the laser gun is well established and dates back to the 1890's, but I asked myself why that is. So, why are laser-based weaponry so popular in the works of science fiction? Kinetic slug-thrower firearms have been around, in one form or another, since the 13th century, and prior to that, battles were fought with swords, axes, spears, and the arrow. All of these ancient weapons share a similar concept, force that propels a metal projectile into the flesh of thy enemy. Even today, our assault rifles used chemical explosions to slam shaped pieces of metal into our enemies. This was not lost on the early creators of the genre of science fiction. The easiest way to setup your fictional tale apart from the contemporary reality was to put a weapon that does not fire metal, but beams of lethal light. While some believe that our obsession with directed-energy weaponry is based in more modern times, history tells us differently. Lightning, while not understood by early man, was a powerful tool of nature, and in the minds of primitive humans, the supernatural forces at work. The power of lightning and its ability to generate fires, were so radically differently from the stone and wood tools/weapons of early man, that light being as a weapon became entrenched in the common consciences of mankind. For example, in the pages of Mahabharat, written sometime around the 8th or 9th century BEC in ancient India, tell us of the great Vimana aircraft that used a form of directed-energy weaponry. In the story of King Salva's struggle with Krishna, he constructed or liberated a great Vimana aircraft and used it to destroy Krishna's city of Dvaraka. Accounts vary by translation, but most tell of an aerial bombardment, some accounts say that the Vimana used lightning bolts, bright projectiles, or even rockets. Lightning was a common tool of the gods to smoke the unworthy right off of the planet.
Using the long held human fascination with light-based weaponry, H.G. Wells would equip his alien invasion force from the red planet with blazing heat-rays wielded by tripod mecha. Given the popularity of this novel, the sci-fi community that followed would pick up on the used of beams over bullets to clearly communicate to the audience that their story and the characters were from the future. With
Flash Gordon, Buck Rogers, the
Lensman series all using lasers, the establishment of the "rule of cool" trope was solidified by the time of the pulp science fiction works of the 1950's and 60's, paving the way for the phasers of
Star Trek in the 1960's, and the blasters of
Star Wars in the 1970's. Throughout my early childhood in the 1980's, laser blasters that fired color beams of death were expected in any sci-fi work, and it would take a film with as much impact as
Star Trek and
Star Wars to dislodge the rule-of-cool associated with frickin' lasers. That film would in 1986, and
ALIENS would establish the new trope of "kinetic weapons are better" that continues today.
Will Laser Guns be Legal for Citizens in the Future?
Here in America, especially in Texas, where FWS is based, guns and the government's role with gun rights is a hotly debated topic, and while most Texans cannot name more than three amendments to the US Constitution, one of them is ALWAYS the 2nd Amendment. Will fights over civilian private ownership of laser DE weapons be an issue we'll face and protest in the future? Would future governments allow for a citizen access to lethal laser DE weaponry? Did the Founding Fathers and Mothers intend for the legal ownership of laser blasters back in December of 1791? To that question, I don't think that the FF/FM could have wrapped their brains around an AK-47, let alone an laser blaster. While one could make the argument about technologically connection to the firearms of the 18th century to modern firearms, there was nothing like the lasers back in the 18th century. I believe that If and when technology allows for compact lethal laser blaster, there WILL NOT be laser guns for sale at your local gun shop in a legal sense. Laser weapons would be untraceable by current law enforcement techniques (and even TV's
CSI) unlike current slugthrowers.
Interestingly enough, laser in the dangerous category, Class IV, are still legal, and recently someone attempted to sell a $3,000 Class IV (where most medical and industrial lasers are classified under) laser weapon on fucking ebay! Of course, most laser that could burn human flesh are still tied to the local power grid. One element that could get laser weapons banned is their ability to blind people, and burn people...however, in 40 states, flamethrowers are still legal. Could Laser rifles/pistol even exist technologically to replace conventional slugthrowers on the civilian market? Laser rifles, if compact enough, would make poor hunting rifles, blowing smoking holes in Bambi. Laser handguns that would serve as home or personal defense would have to be powerful from the first moment to stop an invader...that all means power, and not much longevity for the battery. In those cases that some breaks into your home, your shotgun is still the best for close encounters or even a tomahawk.
While blaster seem perfectly legal in the
Star War universe, as a whole, it seems that science fiction as come down on the anti-laser gun side of the debate. In the
Firefly universe, only the Alliance military and law enforcement are allowed to own laser guns. In Philip K. Dick's
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sleep?, only police and the military can own a laser.The same is true in
The Forever War. When William gets home from service, he attempts to buy a CO2 pocket laser from a gun shop and is turned down. In the common shopping area, he sees cops armed with lasers. This was also the same in Issac Asimov's
Caves of Steel with the blasters that the NYPD carry. It is believed that in the Federation, civilians cannot own firearms or energyarms. I asked Ken Burnside of Ad Astra Games about this question: "
I sincerely doubt that a laser pistol will every supplant a slugthrower. Anyone with a working knowledge of a machine shop and how to weld can make a functional (conventional) pistol. They'll always be cheaper...and a handheld laser gives up the major advantage of a laser-weapon: the accuracy. If you're not shooting a target 30 meters away, a laser's accuracy will be about the same as a slugthrower's for the first shot., the slugthrower will get the second through Nth shot out sooner, and won't be cooking the shooter's hands medium-rare on each trigger-pull."
Science Fiction and Lasers
Found in the pages of one of the firsts modern science fiction stories, H.G. Wells'
War of the Worlds, was the processor to the sci-fi laser gun, the Martian heat-ray mounted to the deadly tripod mecha.Wells' concept of the heat-ray was expanded upon by Garrett P. Serviss'
Edison's Conquest of Mars. A sort-of-revenge-porn sequel to
War of the Worlds that is completely noncanon and not authorized by H.G. Wells. In the serialized newspaper novel, Earth takes its revenge against the Martians by 1898 reverse-engineering their alien technology to construct a Terran space fleet to take the war to the Red Planet. One of the most important technologies used by the invading Terrans was a hand-held micronized version of the Martian Heat-Ray, often called in the text, "disintegrators" or "disintegration ray". This would mark, along with other important firsts in science fiction, the beginning of the connection between sci-fi and the laser gun.
The common terms associated with early laser DEW devices, such as: "blasters", "ray guns" have been around longer than I originally believed, before 1940. The term "blaster" that is commonly associated with
Star Wars was first used in 1925's
The Green Star Waned by Nictzin Dyalhis, and its more military cousin, the "blaster rifle" was first seen in 1937 in the pages of Frank Belknap long Jr.'s
Exiles of the Stratosphere. The term "ray-gun" comes from a heavyweight of Golden Age Science Fiction, John W. Campbell, and appears in his 1930 story
The Black Star Passes. One has to remember that this time, the idea of lasers, in scientific terms, only came about in 1917 paper by none other than Albert Einstein and the acronym "LASER" was created in 1957 by American physicist Gordon Gould. This would make sense that the first use of the term "laser rifle" came about in 1966 from a story by Poul Anderson.
Another way to track the rather funny terms used in sci-fi works for futuristic weaponry, is examining the pages of the much beloved early sci-fi hero:
Buck Rogers. For many, the original
Buck Rogers was their first introduction to the classic ray-gun that dates back to 1929. Originally, the comic strip talked about "disintegrators" being in used in 2419 AD. However, over the years of the strip and the accompanying ray-gun toys, the method of zapping enemies changed. From disintegration rays (1935), to micro-rockets from a "rocket pistol" (1935), to U-235 powered "Atomic Pistol" after World War II, and the "Sonic Ray Gun" of the Cold War-era. Of course, by the time of the 1980
Buck Rogers TV series that I watched as a wee one, everyone on sci-fi was using a
Star War-ish blaster pistol, keeping with the times. Even godlike Isaac Asimov used the term blaster to describe the futuristic sidearm of C-5 detective Elijah Baley in his 1954 novel
Caves of Steel. However, science fiction directed-energy weaponry would see an explosion in popularity with the advent of sci-fi cinema.
In the landmark sci-fi films:
The War of the Worlds (1953) and
The Forbidden Planet (1956). In the blockbuster 1953 remake of the classic
War of the Worlds, the tripods were replaced by butterfly looking UFO saucers armed with a modernized heat-ray that baked soldiers and civilians in ashes. In the also groundbreaking
The Forbidden Planet, our brave Earth space heroes use the Colt-Vickers Atomic Fission Rifle that fired pulses of colored light, and was not referred to as a "laser gun" due to the world "laser" not being created until 1957.
With the advent of the term "laser", sci-fi creators quickly adopted the term into works of the day, and there was no going back. From the 1960's onward, becoming the laser gun was the go-to sci-fi weapon, and became rooted in the popular imagination with
Star Trek and
Star Wars. However, sci-fi depicted of lasers runs from seriously scientific to laughably comic with slow moving lasers that could be dodged. Science fiction creators also had mixed opinions about the effectiveness of their laser weaponry. Some had the laser as end-all-be-all of future weapons and then on the other hand, some projected the laser as the bottom of a future military's armory. While
The Forever War and the blasters of
Star Wars and the phasers of
Star Trek were all more "realistic" laser DEW devices that were the top of the sci-fi weapon food chain.
This was counter balanced by the "weak laser" trend found in sci-fi works like: space fighter laser cannons in the
Wing Commander video games, the Marine laser blaster pistol from
QUAKE: II, and the heat blasters of the Ants from
Armor. By the 1980's, the popularity of the laser peaked, fueled by toys like
Lazer Tag,
Photon and the massive popularity of
Trek/
Wars. Even
Batman got in the laser-craze with the 1990 then-cutting-edge computer art graphic novel of
Batman: Digital Justice. In that work by Pepe Moreno, the grandson of Commissar Gordon, became
Batman with a 21st century suit with an arm-mounted Laser DEW emitter that fired from the palm, like
Iron Man. With the coming of
ALIENS in 1986, the laser blaster was soon replaced as the go-to weapon of sci-fi with slugthrowers in both cased and caseless varieties. We can see this trend alive and well in works like
Elysium, HALO, and
AVATAR, and the rebooted
Battlestar Galactica. Of course, laser guns are still around, seen in works like
DUST-514, and most likely always will be.
Why Are Phaser Not On the List?
Easily the phaser from
Star Trek is one of the beloved, recognized, and popular science fiction directed-energy weapons...so, why is not on the list of realistic laser weapon examples? While
Trek started out using those laser pistols in the first two pilots, Gene Roddenberry originally intended for the hand-weapon of
Trek to be a Photon Maser and to be called a "phaser", because lasers were not commonly known in the mid-1960's. It was not really until
ST:TNG that the mystery of what exactly the phaser fired, and the answer was not a laser beam. Instead, the phasers, specifically, the
TNG phasers use a rapid pulse nadion effect that creates a pulsed protonic charge in the artificial LiCu 521 crystal matrix in the operational portion of the phaser. The barrel assembly focuses the discharge into a coherent beam. That is straight out of the 1991
ST: TNG Technical Manual. That being said, I do not believe that the phaser, while certain a DEW device, is not a laser weapon. In the near future, FWS will be writing an entire
Weapons of Sci-Fi blogpost lavishly detailing the phaser and its evolution. Because that is one of the areas in which the phaser is unique in all of sci-fi, a weapon that evolves over time, step by step...but, it isn't a laser.
Examples of "Realistic" Lasers in Science Fiction
The JDF Araska HLR-12X Heavy Laser Rifle from Akira
This 1988 OVA adoption of the massive manga series is often hailed as one of the best anime of all time, and for a number of years, served as the "ambassador" anime until the arrival of
Cowboy Bebop. While I am NOT a fan of this jumbled mess of a film, and the simply bad voice acting associated with the original American OVA release, it does feature a rather realistic MILSPEC DE weapon. During the climax of both the
Akira OVA and manga, the Japanese military laser rifle, the ARASKA HLR 12X, makes an appearance to stop the out-of-control transforming Tetsuo. There is little official information on the laser rifle itself, and the design varies from manga to anime to toy. However, the overall design remains the same: shoulder slung battery pack, Bazooka-like laser weapon, and the two married via a cord.
In the OVA, the military attempts to stop and regain control of the crisis and madness washing over Neo-Tokyo with soldiers, tanks, and the experimental beam rifle. During the street battle between the military and Tetsuo, the soldiers armed with the beam rifle occupy a bridge and engage the "gifted" child. When the beams fail to kill or haul the god-child, the soldiers narrow the beam and try again. Tetsuo slaughters them. As Kaneda and Kay are giving chase to Tetsuo, they come across the dead soldiers and their ARASKA HLR 12X. It is during the final fight between Kaneda and Tetsuo that we see the largest screen time for the beam rifle. It is during this fight, that the laser rifle runs out of charge. Later on, Kaneda attempts to use his futuristic badass bike to charge up the battery pack. The OVA plays around with the effectiveness of the laser from scene to scene.
In the 5th volume of the massive
Akira manga, around page 309, Kaneda is given the beam rifle by a member of the Clowns street bike gang named Joker. Joker tells Kaneda that the laser gun is a prototype and dangerous, but never refers to it by any proper name, just like the anime. Much like the OVA, Kaneda confronts Number-41 Tetsuo, firing several times at him, with the HLR 12X. Unlike the anime, the manga laser rifle as a much wider beam that appears more flamethrower than DE beam. The laser rifle itself along with Kaneda and the red future bike have become symbols of
Akira. Even today, many years after the anime and manga release, you can still buy official high-quality statues of Kaneda wielding the beam rifle. So, what is up with the name of this laser beam rifle? I was unable to discovery the origin of the name itself and why certain sites call the laser rifle, the "ARASKA HLR 12X". I believe that the name originated from some of the original Kaneda statue model kits released around the time of the OVA, but that is just a guess. If we dig deeper on the name "Araska", it is very close to the name of an actually Japanese arms designer, Arisaka Nariakira, whose bolt-action rifles were used from 1897 until the end of World War II. The "HLR 12X", means
Heavy
Laser
Rifle, and "12X" refers to the model name of the beam rifle. Interestingly enough, the IMFDB.org page on
Akira calls the 12X an "particle accelerator cannon" which is not mentioned in the anime or manga. Why is the
Akira laser rifle on this list? The HLR 12X is presented realistically in terms of design, and in the case of the anime OVA, with realistic output and being connected to a battery pack. However, following the case of the majority of laser DEW devices, the beam is visible.
The Ship-board Lasers from Babylon 5
Babylon 5 mixed technologically levels across the races of the Milky Way, some were uber advanced, while others, including Earth, were still moving up the ladder. According to several sources, the main Narn warship, the
G'Quan class heavy crusier had twin hard-mounted 2,500 gigawatt X-ray laser cannons designed to be the main offensive armament of the class. To put that in some perspective, the entire power output for the United States wind turbines is around 10,000 gigawatts.
This would require a massive amount of power (and cooling) to operate these bad boys. Much like the Narn, the famous Earth Alliance
Omega class destroyer uses similar offense laser batteries and also like the Narn heavy cruiser, it is the first weapon used during combat. For the on-screen usage, the naval laser cannons are used like enormous cutting beam to slice and dice through enemy hull armor, damaging a wide portion of the enemy warship. While the system is powerful, it is low-tech in the
B5 universe, and it does not feature rapid fire capability. The laser weaponry of
B5 commits the same crime against science that money every DEW devices does...visible beams of death.
The AMT Hardballer Longslide .45 ACP from The Terminator
Okay, I know it is a dick move to put a laser sight on the list, but this one is special. While laser-based aiming devices are small, cheap, and common today (I used to have one an old paintball gun), way back in 1984, they were cutting edge technology. In one of the groundbreaking 1980's sci-fi movies,
The Terminator, the T-101 time traveler/assassin was armed with what now as become an iconic weapon of sci-fi, the laser sight longslide .45. Who can forget when Arnold broke into that other Sarah Conner's house, put the red dot on her forehead, and blasted away. The original prop laser aiming device was developed by Ed Reynolds of SureFire, then called Laser Products. Unlike today's solid state laser aiming devices, the
Terminator laser sight was helium neon. While the laser device in the film looks self-contained, like today's, this little baby needed 10,000 volts used to turn on, and another 1,000 to keep the laser active.
This thirst device required that a separate battery pack and cord were hidden under the M65 field jacket of Arnold Schwarzenegger. Two props were built for the film, one was the hero prop with the laser and power pack, the other was a shell. One thing I've been unable to verify about the laser device in
Terminator is if the effect on-screen is the laser from the pistol or if it is a special visual effect done after the filming. My guess, considering the work that went into the prop, was that most of the shots of the laser in use, were the laser device in the real world.
The Lasers from the Firefly universe
One of the most interesting science fiction properties of the 21st century is
Firefly (that Fox fucking cancelled!!)and also just as interesting and original when it comes to the topic of laser weapons. Mentioned several times in the TV series was that normal citizens could not own laser weapons, and only the Alliance police and military were allowed. However, some of the powerful and wealthy of the Verse society could buy a permit to allow for legal ownership. Much of the weaponry seen in the series are kinetic slugthrowers, especially on the outer planets. Most that lived beyond the reach of the Alliance didn't want to relay on the core worlds for anything, and normal firearms allowed them to do just that. Also, given the origins of the Independence movement that led to the bloody Unification War, the Alliance didn't want laser weaponry to fall into the hands of their former enemies, especially if another coup occurred.
In the episode "Trash", the story centers around the progenitor to all modern laser technology in The Verse, the Lassiter. Name for Pixar animator John Lasseter, this bulky pistol laser gun looks more like a future cleaning appliance than a deadly laser-zapper. The reason behind the bulky appearance of the ancient Lassiter laser gun was the object that the prop was constructed around: a 1980's rechargeable flashlight with a pivot lamp head. During the 1980's, these big flashlights were everywhere, hell, even my grandparents had one and they sucked, and these were built by companies like First Alert, and Archer. In one of the last episodes "Heart of Gold", we got to see the modern equality to the Lassiter, in the hands of scumbag rancher Rance Burgess, "the Silk Trigger Active Return Bolt Laser Pistol". While the laser pistol was effective, it ran quickly out of charge with continued firing.
In the 2005 film, all of the Alliance military personnel are seen with DEW devices, in contrast to the crew of the
Serenity. The prop guns used by the filmmakers on
Serenity were actually Psycho Ballistics Silver Bullet Paintball markers, and Worr Game Products Autocockers, all from around 2004.
The UNDF Veritech Valkyrie Laser Cannon from ROBOTECH: Macross
Prior to the 1st ROBOTECH War, the newly formed United Earth Gov't, began a project to solve the question if and when the alien owners of the SDF-1 showed back up, what would Earth counter the threat with. How would Earth's finest defend against alien giants with guns? In 2002, the UNDF embarked on a project to construct the Veritech, a transformable aircraft that could fight in air and on the ground. The first prototype was flown in 2006 with Roy Fokker at the controls. By the time that Breetai's fleet showed up, the Veritech
Valkyrie is well into production, and becomes the main attack mecha of the 1st ROBOTECH War, and one of the most iconic Japanese mecha of all time.
Normally, the
Valkyries seen on-screen used hailstorms of missiles, and the monstrous Hughes GU-11 55mm tri-barreled smoothbore rotary cannon/gun pod. Used less often was the
Valkyrie head-mounted laser cannon, that was seen in various forms during
Macross. In the pages of the ROBOTECH RPG, the laser is known as the Mauser RoV-20 Laser cannon that is in single, double, or quad emitters. During most of the series, the Mauser RoV-20 DEW is used to slice through metal, as in Rick rescuing Lisa from Alaska Base, and the attempted escape from Breetai's flag ship. It is explained in several sources that the lasers were used more often during air-to-air engagements while the SDF-1 was making it's way back from Pluto to Earth, due to the limited supplies of ammunition. I went back and watched several battlescenes during this time frame of
Macross, and it seems that while the
Valkyrie is in fighter mode, the underslung laser emitter is used. However, there is continuity errors with their on-screen usage. While the single emitter style on Ben and Max's Veritechs emit a beam, the quad-emitter on SKULL-One, is shown either as a pulse laser or beams.
The XMLR-1A/3A Experimental Laser Rifles from G.I. Joe
Way back in the early 1980's, my first
GI Joe figure was Flash, and yes, I totally bought because he had a laser gun, I'll admit it. With this connection, he was one of my favorite characters in the cartoon and Marvel Comic book series that my brother collected. There was something oddly realistic about the gun, called an XMLR-1A, with its battery backpack and cord attached to a semi-rifle looking weapon. Flash himself looked the part with a thermal patting and a mirrored vision on his helmet. According to the official information, the XMLR stood for E
xperimental
Military
Laser
Rifle and was developed in 1980, and handed over to GI Joe for testing and combat evaluation to see if the technology should adopted by the entire US military. One of the big drawbacks to the XMLR-1A was the limited battery life: ten "pulsed "shots could be used or one hour of beam time before the battery was drained. In the early issues of the Marvel comic book, it was a realistic narrow, but visible beam. and the other Joe members used normal slugthrowers.
Of course, the dumb 1980's American cartoon had all of COBRA and GI Joe using lasers instead of rifles, while the figures came with all manner of realistic weaponry. That laser rifle actually came from another figure I owned, Snowjob, and that was an improved version called the XMLR-3A. This laser DE Rifle was meant to be shown as the next step in hand-held MILSPEC DEW technology. In the original toyline, COBRA didn't have their own laser weaponry, however, in the cartoon they used a weapon very similar to the XMLR-3A. COBRA would get a laser trooper of their own in the 1990 "Laser-Viper" figure. The toys would also have laser DEW devices in the H.I.S.S tank, the L.A.W. and H.A.L laser artillery cannons...after all, it was the 1980's. Let us not even speak of that other
GI Joe laser trooper Sci-Fi and his role in the forgotten
GI JOE: Starbrigade toyline...which FWS will be covering much later.
Sgt. Ramsay's Laser Weapon from Runaway (1984)
In those long ago time in distant past that we call the 1980's, Tom Selleck was a major star with a legendary mustache that has its own star on the Hollywood Walk of Fame. During his run on
Magnum P.I., he made a little known science fiction film directed and written by none other than Michael Crichton. The basic plot of the film
Runaway is that robots are common place in the near future, and like any other machine it is either a benefit or hazard. If they are a benefit, than it is not the concern of Tom Selleck's character Sgt. Ramsay, a veteran officer the Los Angeles Police Department's Rep-Detect Blade Runner Squad...oops...I meant Runaway Squad. His thanksless job is to hunt down rouge and dangerous machines and retire them with his realistic hand-held laser weapon that is tied to a power-pack on his belt. Oddly, realistic in usage and power for a 1980's movie, sadly it is not used often in the film, but it should be noted in this forgotten film.
The Laser DEWs in the ALIENS universe
The
ALIENS universe as always done things a little differently than most sci-fi works, and laser weaponry is never used on-screen. In the original 1979 movie, despite the crew of the cargo vehicle
Nostromo having laser pistols, they choice to go after the xenomorph with homebrew flamethrowers! If we read between the lines, the reason why the crew didn't zap the alien was it would have made a terrible movie, and possible that the creature's acid-for-blood would have not reacted well to a high-powered laser beam. That laser pistol, seen only on-screen briefly, was rigged more to be "blaster" like rather realistic, with oddball bits and pieces attached to the DE pistol. It would never been seen again in the
ALIENS universe. Some time ago, FWS did profile this weapon in much detail for a
Weapons of Sci-Fi blogpost...read that if you would like to know more.
Jumping ahead 57 years, laser weaponry is now in common use with the military organizations of Earth, including our beloved Colonial Marine Corps. If we examine the holy pages of the
ALIENS: Colonial Marine Technical Manual, we can find that lasers were indeed present on the battlefield in various roles. Most of the US Army's and CMC's armored vehicles, use laser DEW emitters in the 40MW range as AAA defense, and I believe from the text, most of this is handled by the vehicle's computer automatically. Point-defense is also the main combat role of laser emitters on the USASF. For example, the
Conestoga class (
Sulaco) uses 80MW free-electron lasers for intercept of incoming rail rounds, missiles, and fighters.
When it comes to laser DEWs being used in an offensive role, the Colonial Marines have two offensive laser DEW devices. One is the mounted to M577A2 APC, which uses twin emitter Republic Dynamics M2025 40MW free-electron lasers in the 2.0-3.0 micron range. This weapon system is able to counter threats from both ground and air. The operator of the main gun on the APC has several options, the A2 FEL DEW can be used in low-power mode to "dazzle" pilots and infantry, blinding them without the need for dwelling time. In direct-fire full-power mode, the M2025 pulses the beam to burn through the armor of any threat and is effective, barring any atmospheric conditions, up to 3,000 meters. However, in practice, gunners onboard the M577A2 APC never pulse anything above 1,000 meters due to atmospheric scattering, resulting in a less powerful beam that could allow the target to take countermeasures to the APC. In the movie
ALIENS, that M577 APC was an "A3", mounting twin 20 MeV particle beam cannons, which was the most recently addition to the M577 family of vehicles. Then there is the UA 571-D remote sentry weapon system that uses a 20MW hydrogen fluoride laser beam instead of the more common UA 571-C model that uses the 10x28mm caseless round, as seen in the film.
The Exelion Laser Cannons from Gunbuster
Gunbuster is anime military sci-fi/giant space robot six-part series developed by Gainax studios, the same studio that developed
Royal Space Force: the Wings of Honnesamise and
Neon Genesis Evangelion. I would rent these series in the mid-1990's on their U.S. Renditions release, but it has been a long damn time ago...I think I still had long hair when I watched this one! Anyway, the flagship of the Earth fleet, the
Exelion and the testing site of the Gunbuster mech was fitted with rather realistic laser emitters that appears more like cameras than World War One artillery pieces. We even see crew members going on EVAs to clean the laser DEW lens...never seen that before in a sci-fi. This makes the ship-broad laser emitters of
Gunbuster unique.
The Laser Weapons from The Forever War
In the pages of one of the greatest military sci-fi novels of all time: Joe Haldman's
The Forever War. The UN mission to confront the hostile aliens is manned with genius-level soldiers that clothed in powered armor fighting suits and armed with CO2 "finger lasers". These effect of these laser DE weapons is shown in all of it gory details on the local wildlife on Epsilon Aurigae and the Taurans. When the expeditionary forces arrives back on a much changed Earth decades later, William Mandella attempted to buy a "pocket CO2 laser" for personal protection, but it refused due to lasers being legal for cops and military. Instead, he buys a shotgun-revolver loaded with flechettes. In the 1988 Dutch-French-American graphic novel series done by Marvano and published by Dupuis in Europe and NBM in American, the UNEF is armed with lasers, but take the form of military laser assault rifles, similar in design to the
Star Wars Rebel Alliance A280 and A295 blaster rifles.
The Misriah Armory M6 Grindell/Galilean Nonlinear Rifle from the HALO Universe
Weighting in at 42 lbs unloaded, and 45 lbs, loaded, the UNSC M6 Grindell/Galilen Nonlinear Rifle or the "SPARTAN Laser" is one massive DEW deivce and contrary to the nickname, the M6 G/GNR is wielded by non-super-soldier UNSC soldiers, like the ODSTs. The role of the M6 G/GNR is anti-material that is designed to counter the Covenant's Hunters,
Wraith tanks, and the
Banshee aircraft. Originally created under Project: GUNGNIR, the M6 G/GNR would be seen more during the final years of the wars, especially in 2552, and used in-field to disable alien vehicles, and the larger alien combat species.
In operation, the M6 G/GNR takes about three long seconds to spin-up to fire a ruby-red laser DE charge of considerable power. During pre-fire, the M6 G/GNR, produces a guide-aiming laser to the target, to prompt for aim adjustments. Often, when this mother fucker fires, it destroy the target completely, however, it punishes the user for misfires and bad aim, often resulting in death. In the post-Humn/Covenant War period, the redesigned
Pelican tactical transport/gunship mounts a vehicle variant of the M6 G/GNR, called the M8C G/GNC. Bungie developed this massive laser weapon for
HALO 3 and has been seen in every
HALO game that followed along with an appearance in the shitty
HALO anime,
Legends. I remember back when
HALO 3 was under development, that Bungie included this rare human DEW to add some variation to the UNSC mega-damage weaponry, and despite the power of the MG G/GNR, Bungie wisely fitted it with counter balances. I personally believe that the M6 G/GNR was developed as a lightweight personal artillery piece, to counter the aliens' advantage.
At the lab, they link up with the sensei and arms supplier of the Heartbreakers, Tex Takeda. The goal of the surviving clones and the doctor is to get to the spaceport and hijack a shuttle off-world. At the close of the DHP#36, all hell breaks loose, with BioVoc soldiers storming the lab, as one element of the Heartbreakers engages them, while the remains of the Deltas, some of the Betas, Sorenson and Tex all make down the sewer pipes. While in the pipes, they encounter the racial street gang Black Sting led by an old girlfriend of Tex's, and she agrees to help them out escaping from Ward and BioVoc. Again, another desperate battle is fought by the Heartbreakers at the spaceport. During this bloody battle, Queenie, the commanding Beta clone of the Queen of Clubs, is wounded, but the lose of more sisters is worth it, Sorenson and some of her clones make it off-world, just as Ward also takes BioVoc off-world to their new HQ on Titan. 
Back in 1989, this was my introduction to the world of HEARTBREAKERS, and after reading the other two Dark Horse HEARTBREAKERS comics, this is the most seminal work of these cloned lady warfighters. The background was not fleshed out, so in some ways that drives the mind of the reader to seek out answers and dwell on the work long after you've read it (especially if you're me). Plus, the art is rich and prefect for the black&white format, the Heartbreakers look like Colonial Marines, and the military aspect is stronger here than any HEARTBREAKERS works hence. Seriously, you can stare that the panels and pick little details on the gear of the femme fatales. Everything here is tightly controlled due to the limit of the space, and it really works. Considering the other two series that followed, I have to say that I enjoyed this story much more, and I count this 1989 comic as one of my influences for my own military sci-fi stories, and the story itself still holds up. 
The clone cyborg assassin Rusk is being trained against clones of Queenie, and Queenie and Tex hook up. Due to the media attention, some people have approached Tex and Queenie about becoming Heartbreakers themselves. The matrix is used again, transforming these volunteers into Heartbreakers. Queenie instead of Tex goes out to buy some more arms for the new gals when she is captured by Rusk and hauled back to BioVoc. Ward, now on Earth, wants Queenie to be the bait for Vector to come and rescue her, so he can have Sorenson's cloning research and the matrix. So, a rescue mission ensues. Rusk is injected by Malinthe's lab with the matrix, and he goes fucking nuts, and nearly kills Malinthe, but she infected with the matrix. During the rescue attempt, Malinthe, now horribly mutated attacks and kills Ward. During the last few panels we see the truth behind Ward and a connection to the old First Comics military sci-fi series Dynamo Joe. At this point, the new Heartbreakers ally themselves with LONE, and rush off to help out clone workers. Thus ends the last of the HEARTBREAKERS comics. 
Oh gods...where do I start? In a word, series three is a mess. While the story of clone rights and the battle of the belt by BioVoc is all very interesting, it is smothered in over-the-top-John-Woo gun-play that the reader can plainly see is all to worship the Queenie character. Realistic military tactics be damned! Queenie jumps in the line of fire, dual-wielding pistols, and spray the landscape with leads. All of these is played for style points, and it rings hollow. It just is too much, and causes the comic to lose focus and the theme of the original 1989 series. It also doesn't help that Paul wasn't doing the art in issue #3 and #4, and that entire subplot of the matrix and the Rusk cyborg clone assassin. None of these events were organic, and come off to be self-serving. All of this was just too much for me, and the reader feedback mail in the back of each comic supports the same issues that I had. Out of all the HEARTBREAKERS series published by Dark Horse, this 1996 series is the most disappointing. Very quickly after this series was published, Paul and Anina abandoned the John Wood gun play style, for more kung-fu clones actions. 
Back in 1989, I was in middle school, and beginning my exploration of darker science fiction that the my normal doses of Trek, Wars, and Asimov novels. ALIENS introduced me to a world of science fiction that was more real and dealt with topics that peaked my interest. Around this time, Dark Horse Comics was publishing their ALIENS and Predator comics, which I was collecting, and they were teasing the upcoming ALIENS vs. Predator limited series in a prequel storyline in the pages of Dark Horse Presents. Plus, it helped the sources that Paul and Anina drew from, like Full Metal Jacket, ALIENS, and BLADE RUNNER were all favorites of mine, and still are. In was in those pages that I discovered HEARTBREAKERS. However, the HEARTBREAKERS story was only in two of the ALIENS vs. Predator DHP comics, and therefore, I never read the ending of the 1989 series one HEARTBREAKERS until just recently. When I started FWS in 2010, I decided that HEARTBREAKERS should be mentioned, and I began to research the world of HEARTBREAKERS. Thankfully, Lone Star Comics had all of the back issues, and I bought series two and three, along with the conclusion to series one. Instead of being a teenager reading the adventures of the cloned soldiers and scientists, I was in my 30's, writing my own MSF, and that may have altered my POV on the comics themselves. As I said above, HEARTBREAKERS was one of my influences on my first military sci-fi novel.
.jpg)
.jpg)
.gif)
